Cash offers for homes in Nashotah 53058

The 53058 ZIP code covers 1,158 single-family homes in Nashotah. Find your street below, or jump straight to your address.

Homes

1,158

Median value

$601,700

Median cash offer

$540,945

Absentee-owned

13%

Streets in 53058

Notable properties in 53058

5162 N Maple Ln$9,202,860–$9,202,860
4978 N Maple Ln$5,159,070–$5,159,070
3701 Trinity Ln$4,633,020–$4,633,020
3501 Trinity Ln$4,520,520–$4,520,520
5884 N County Road C$4,045,410–$4,045,410
3101 Seminary Ridge Ln$4,019,490–$4,019,490
W335n5495 Island View Ln$4,004,910–$4,004,910
W330n6209 Hasslinger Dr$3,863,340–$3,863,340
3601 Trinity Ln$3,551,850–$3,551,850
3301 Seminary Ridge Ln$3,492,180–$3,492,180
5106 N Maple Ln$3,355,380–$3,355,380
W332n6125 County Road C$3,332,160–$3,332,160
W342n4976 Oak Ln$3,250,890–$3,250,890
3801 Trinity Ln$3,052,260–$3,052,260
W336n5535 Island View Ln$3,034,440–$3,034,440
3201 Seminary Ridge Ln$2,756,430–$2,756,430
W339n5342 Township Road O$2,692,800–$2,692,800
W335n5511 Island View Ln$2,612,700–$2,612,700
3401 Seminary Ridge Ln$2,524,500–$2,524,500
5928 N Oakland Rd$2,518,290–$2,518,290
W334n5832 Garvin Ln$2,482,740–$2,482,740
W334n6010 Township Road M$2,482,650–$2,482,650
N57w33307 Township Road M$2,395,890–$2,395,890
W331n6210 County Road C$2,367,990–$2,367,990
5270 N Maple Ln$2,343,330–$2,343,330
N57w33301 Township Road M$2,338,650–$2,338,650
W339n5323 Township Road O$2,293,290–$2,293,290
W339n5183 Township Road O$2,289,510–$2,289,510
W338n5221 Township Road O$2,258,730–$2,258,730
3500 Red Chapel Ct$2,188,440–$2,188,440
W334n6030 Township Road M$2,178,000–$2,178,000
N40w32640 Nashotah Ave$2,166,030–$2,166,030
W336n5500 Island View Ln$2,148,390–$2,148,390
4804 N Pinecrest Dr$1,805,454–$2,123,921
W339n5097 Road O$2,101,860–$2,101,860
W340n4811 Township Road O$2,085,840–$2,085,840
W335n5549 Island View Ln$2,063,970–$2,063,970
N58w33409 Township Road M$2,025,630–$2,025,630
W330n6233 Hasslinger Dr$2,023,200–$2,023,200
5892 N Oakland Rd$1,978,290–$1,978,290
W334n5809 Garvin Ln$1,976,940–$1,976,940
5964 N Oakland Rd$1,940,400–$1,940,400
N48w34076 Jaeckles Dr$1,932,570–$1,932,570
W336n5505 Island View Ln$1,932,210–$1,932,210
W334n5995 Township Road M$1,926,900–$1,926,900
5868 N County Road C$1,919,250–$1,919,250
W334n5803 Garvin Ln$1,898,820–$1,898,820
W340n4947 Township Road O$1,892,250–$1,892,250
3400 Red Chapel Ct$1,890,090–$1,890,090
W339n5105 Township Road O$1,888,200–$1,888,200

Recent sales nearby

Address	Sold	Price
2135 W Shore Dr	2026-03-09	$640,000
2115 N Genesee St	2026-01-20	$545,000
1958 Hillcrest Dr	2026-01-12	$668,000
6151 N Oakland Hills Rd	2025-12-19	$1,235,000
2730 Nagawicka Ave	2025-09-29	$440,000
2132 W Shore Dr	2025-08-12	$1,300,000
5188 N County Road C	2025-02-28	$460,000